Lafayette Restaurants |

Sarge Oak at City Centre

American, Steakhouse

This restaurant has closed, Toscana Italian Grill & Bar has opened in its place.

Address: 515 South Street, Lafayette, Indiana
Phone: 765.742.5230
Alcohol? Full Bar, Wine List
Reservations: Accepted
Expect to Spend: $$$-$$$$

One Response to “Sarge Oak at City Centre”

  1. Purdue Maggie says:

    They have new chef, so I will toss my previous bad experiences aside. We had dinner there for New Year’s Eve and the overall experience was decent, but not great or worth the price.

    The atmosphere is good. Very nice lighting and comfortable seating. I felt weird being sat in the middle of the restaurant at a table when four booths were open. I am not sure why they would have made this choice. It caused the three tables in the restaurant at the time to be clustered together.

    The food was good. Our soup, salad, and appetizers were very nice. My husband loved the crab cakes. His ribeye was undercooked and lacked flavor. He loved the sides. My shrimp in a cream sauce was excellent. I loved the rice pilaf. The dessert was horrible. I got the molten chocolate, which was luke warm, runny, chocolate cake batter. I couldn’t eat it.

    The service was lacking. The server was nice and offered suggestions, but inattentive after the order was taken. We did not get rolls with our salad and our drinks were empty. The restaurant has also gone to lipton tea over the full tea service, which was a little disappointing.

    Over, we will give them another shot, but probably wait awhile. The prices are too high for hit or miss service and food.


Leave a Reply

Top Rated Places to Eat